Well, as expected, these were very hit and miss. Some of the colours are really lovely - the greens in particular. And some of them are rubbish, frankly. Along with the crappy packaging, I would have been really annoyed if I had paid full price for these. However, I didn't, so over all I'm reasonably happy with them.
As you can see, caking is a bit of a problem with many of them. In the first couple of photos I was swatching with a damp brush but that was just creating clumps, so I switched to swatching them dry over lip balm. It wasn't much better. It will take some work to figure out how to make the best of these, which is kind of annoying. Eyeshadow should not be work.